expr:class='"loading" + data:blog.mobileClass'>

Thursday, December 31, 2015

The Good and Bad of 2015

Until Tuesday, it had been 25 years since I last visited Battle Ground. Back in the day, I frequented the area as a substitute teacher. Tuesday's trip was a beer excursion. I was checking out Barrel Mountain Brewing for an upcoming review.

Battle Ground was a pretty quiet town in the old days. The population in 1990 was less than 3,800 according to Census numbers. The estimated population in 2014 was nearly 19,000. Obviously, a lot has changed. There's a growing, bustling business district now. There was nothing like that in 1990. 

Barrel Mountain Brewing is a pleasing and, I'm quite sure, welcome addition to the local scene. Since opening last summer, they've built a following with a nice selection of beers and a menu I'd describe as standard-plus pub fare. 

I'll have more to say about Barrel Mountain in Willamette Week's 2016 Beer Guide, which hits news stands in February. For now, it serves as an example of possibly the most positive trend of 2015, that being the trend of small breweries expanding into suburban and rural settings. 

Having worked in Clark County from 1990 to 2009, I watched a few breweries come and go. But it was mostly a dead zone. Over the course of the last few years, things have turned. Residents are no longer forced to traverse the Columbia River to find good beer. They can find it closer to home. 

The current trend was obviously a long time coming. For many years, you had to wonder when it would happen, if it would happen. There are a lot of underserved areas, like Battle Ground, that are starved for good beer and ready to support a brewery or breweries. Finally, it's happening.

Of course, the trend isn't strictly confined to suburban or rural areas. Many underserved boroughs in cities are also getting breweries or craft-centric pubs. What's different and especially positive is that the craft movement is spreading to suburbia and the countryside. 

Some fear the US brewery count, which now exceeds 4,000, is untenable. For production breweries, there surely is a limit. But there are an almost endless number of viable locations available to small, brewpub-type operations. Expansion into these areas will likely continue in 2016. 

That's the good news.

On the Other Hand
Probably the most negative aspect of the current craft beer scene is the accelerating pace of sellouts to big beer. The list for 2015 is long and includes Elysian (Washington), Four Peaks (Arizona), Golden Road, Ballast Point and Lagunitas (California), and Breckenridge (Colorado),

No one I know expects the pace of acquisitions to slow. Big beer market share is plummeting. Craft beer market share is growing. Big beer recognizes that tasteless, mass market lagers don't have a bright future. So they're investing in the guys they can't beat. 

I have to admit being less bothered by the buyouts, which I expect, than by the reaction to them by some in the industry. There are those who see the buyouts as nothing more than some sort of natural progression in which big beer embraces craft beer as it's own and moves on.

Nothing could be further from the truth. Big beer, particularly Anheuser-Busch, is buying craft brands so it can use them to leverage its position. They want to blur the perception of what craft beer is and squeeze market access via vertical integration wherever possible, to the detriment of independent craft brewers. 

I'm truly astounded when I hear people praising what the acquired breweries are doing. "Look at all the creative beers they're brewing." It doesn't matter in the least. These breweries enjoy significant advantages over independent craft brewers. It isn't close to an even playing field.

As noted, I fully expect the buyouts to continue. What I'd like to see in 2016 is more widespread recognition of what the buyouts mean for the industry as we've known it. I doubt it will happen, but I can always hope.

There's every reason to believe 2016 will be another highly interesting, entertaining year in beer. I look forward to watching it unfold. Happy New Year to all!

Saturday, December 26, 2015

Anatomy of a Buyout...and Buyouts to Come

After the buyouts of 10 Barrel in 2014 and Elysian in early 2015, I figured Anheuser-Busch would soon add California and Colorado breweries to its trophy case. There was nothing sophisticated about that supposition. It was based on the fact these are top tier craft beer states.

Of course, the California buyout happened a while ago, when AB purchased Golden Road Brewing of Los Angeles. That was out of nowhere because there are fatter targets in the Golden State. The more recent buyout of Arizona-based Four Peaks Brewing was another surprise. But never mind.

The buyout of Colorado's Breckenridge is different. Perusing some of the published and proprietary reports, the acquisition makes a lot of sense for Anheuser-Busch. It represents a significant effort to improve a dreadful ground game and end a lengthy downward spiral.

Since 2007, AB has seen it's business decline by 17 percent in Colorado. Put another way, it lost 263,000 barrels in volume. I don't have the detailed numbers, but you know the losses, like those they've suffered in other states, are in the premium segment. The entire Budweiser family is in free fall, getting beaten to a pulp by craft beer. Not exactly breaking news.

The addition of Breckenridge is a plausible antidote. Colorado's fifth largest craft brewer will stop and potentially reverse nearly a decade of negative AB momentum. The brewery reportedly does 45 percent of its business in Colorado, selling around 30,000 bbls in a state of over 3 million bbls, and grew 10 percent in-state this year.

Breckenridge also has reach and potential outside Colorado, Although it is distributed in 35 states, it does 60 percent of its total business in Colorado, Texas and Ohio. So it's spread thinly in the remaining 32 states. Which means there is significant potential to expand on those numbers via the AB network in those states.

That's all real nice, but there's more going on here. AB's grand strategy is connected to how it is leveraging its business in Oregon, Washington and California, where lax laws allow it to vertically integrate via the ownership of breweries, distributor and retail outlets. That's what it's doing in Colorado.

The stats are clear. Prior to 2015, AB owned a brewery in Fort Collins and a distributor in Denver. During 2015, it acquired Breckenridge (a deal that won't close until 2016) and two additional distributors (Standard and American Eagle). As part of the Breckenridge deal, AB gets two breweries and two retail locations. Plus, it will open a 10 Barrel brewpub in Denver in 2016. By the end of next year, AB will own four breweries, three distributors and three retail locations in Colorado. They have dramatically expanded their footprint across the three tiers in the state.

What does this gibberish mean? It means that if you want to know where the next AB acquisitions are likely to occur, look for high-growth breweries that produce 50K or more barrels a year, have pubs and, perhaps most importantly, reside in states where the laws allow AB to operate in all three tiers.

The suits in St. Louis may very well look outside areas where they already have a craft presence in 2016. But my guess is they aren't done in Colorado, California, Oregon or Washington. Unless the three tier laws are firmed up in those states, there are too many fat targets to ignore.

Thursday, December 17, 2015

Indiana's Goofy Cold Beer Law Lives On

When you look out on the beer landscape, you see a lot of crazy shit. Some states have relaxed their laws and made it easier for small breweries to do business. But there are other states where the laws remain as antiquated as ever. Like Indiana.

It turns out the Hoosier state is one of the few places in the country where you cannot buy cold beer in grocery and convenience stores. That's right. If you want cold beer to go in Indiana, you have to buy it in a liquor store. Beer bought in standard stores is not chilled.

This policy has been a thorn in the behind of the Indiana Petroleum Marketers and Convenience Store Association, which has lobbied for years to get the law changed. Frustration reached the point where they filed suit against the state in May 2013, claiming the law to be discriminatory because it allows cold beer sales in some stores and not in others.

The retailers did not win. This past Monday, the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld Indiana's goofy law. A three-judge panel unanimously ruled that the state has broad authority to design regulatory systems for alcohol distribution. In siding with the state, the panel said retailers would have to demonstrate that Indiana's cold-beer regulatory scheme treats members differently for no rational reason related to the state's legitimate interest. 

What "state interest" are we talking about? Funny you should ask..or wonder. Indiana's goofy law is fear-driven. Indiana officials are afraid that relaxing it would result in many more outlets selling cold beer, thus making it easier for minors to buy beer and more difficult to enforce the law.

This is a little hard to fathom, actually. Most states have some pretty simple laws on the books requiring store owners to check ID before selling alcohol to anyone who looks to be under a certain age. They obviously have that in Indiana, but they evidently feel retailers must be closely watched to make sure they enforce the law. And the state just doesn't have the manpower.

But, hey, Indiana isn't the only state with bizarre laws. Much of the old South is still fighting the Civil War while maintaining bizarre alcohol laws written long ago. Closer to home, Utah and Colorado have some rather odd laws regarding the sale of beer that clocks in above a certain ABV. This is what you get when you put the states in charge of regulating alcohol inside their borders.

Here in Oregon, our laws are pretty soft, but it hasn't always been so. For 50 years following Prohibition, we had a bizarre law that made it illegal to sell unpasteurized beer in stores. You could sell it in restaurants and bars, but not in stores. The law was ruled unconstitutional in 1985, around the same time brewpubs became legal.

I do not know how or if Indiana's goofy law affects craft beer or beer in general. They've got 100 or so craft breweries, so they're doing reasonably well in that department. But I have to believe allowing the sale of cold beer in all stores makes sense. It's been fairly successful elsewhere.

The only thing they have to fear is fear itself. And the bogeyman.

Saturday, December 5, 2015

Good News and Elephants in the Living Room

These are wild times in the craft beer industry. That's not exactly front page news, but growth and change is happening at such a shocking pace that heads are spinning. The elephant in the living room is the ongoing challenge represented by big beer.

On the plus side, we recently learned the US brewery count surpassed the old record of 4,131. Perhaps most interesting about that revelation is that the old record was set in 1873, and was followed by a period of intense consolidation, then Prohibition, then more intense consolidation. The shift back to growth began roughly 30 years ago and it's been a crazy ride ever since.

There's more. For example, IPA continues to be the dominant craft style. Big surprise. In fact, one could easily argue the popularity of IPA has overflowed into other styles, many of which are hoppier than ever. And despite the ascending brewery count, there are still thousands of communities that are large enough to support a brewery and don't yet have one.

In the midst of all the good news for craft beer is the black hole of consolidation. The billion dollar Ballast Point buyout is the lead in that part of the story, and has more than a few craft brewers wondering what their place might be worth. Breweries that sold earlier, like 10 Barrel, Elysian and Goose Island, look at the Ballast Point deal and wonder where they went wrong.

Of course, the larger story on the consolidation front is the impending buyout of SABMiller by Anheuser-Busch/InBev. The multi-billion dollar deal has the potential to turn the entire beer world upside down. That reality has raised the hackles of regulatory types and a few yet-to-be-bought politicians.

Now there's news that a group of citizens from Oregon, Washington and California has filed suit in US District Court challenging the ABI/SABMiller deal on the grounds that it will hurt consumers by restricting competition and choice. No kidding. The plaintiffs aren't asking for any money. What they want is the merger stopped.

There's about zero chance of that happening in our current political climate. They'd have about as much luck getting assault rifles banned. There's little doubt the AB/SABMiller merger, which is largely a global play, will wind up being bad news for America's independent craft brewers. But there's no feasible way to stop it. All you can realistically hope to do is mitigate the impact.

The primary threat to independent craft brewers is only indirectly related to AB's acquisition of craft breweries. You can't get too excited about that because they will never own more than a small percentage of the total number of breweries. The threat is on the distribution side, where Anheuser-Busch is working to leverage its influence and limit independent craft brewers access to market.

That's not a joke. A Wall Street Journal story outlines an AB incentive plan that rewards distributors who focus primarily on AB brands. A couple of anonymous distributors spilled the beans, telling the WSJ they can receive incentive payouts of as much as $1.5 million annually if 98 percent of their volume is in AB brands. A distributor in St. Louis just dropped Deschutes because it had to choose between the incentive program and craft.

Look, Anheuser-Busch will never own or have influence over every distributor in this country. There will always be independents that go their own way. But AB has the power, via its owned and affiliated distributors, to make things difficult for independent craft brewers. The strategy outed in the WSJ article is just one part of that effort.

Many casual and some serious beer fans have their heads in the sand, more or less refusing to see the danger. Fine. Those who do see the threat can act against it by refusing to spend money on AB products, including acquired brands like 10 Barrel, Elysian, Goose Island, etc. There's nothing personal about this. It's business. Giving good money to Anheuser-Busch helps fuel the effort to undermine independent craft brewers.

Enough already.

Sunday, November 29, 2015

Holiday Ale Festival's Lump of Coal

Given the rapidly changing aspects of the media landscape, I've wondered for a while which of the various beer festivals would be the first to pull the rug on broad media support. Almost on cue, I learned the Holiday Ale Festival will not issue media credentials this year. Viola!

For the unaware, a "media credential" is just a fancy way of saying the event provides writers and reporters with a small subsidy in the form of a glass, tokens and (in this case) comped entry as an incentive to attend. The package is best viewed as a sort of starter kit. Most buy additional tokens once inside.

In exchange for the freebies, media outlets provide coverage in the form of previews and reviews. What the Festival is saying by not issuing credentials is that it no longer needs the support of smaller outlets, particularly blogs.

You may fairly wonder why I say blogs are the primary target. It's pretty simple. Most blogs, even those that have a lot of followers, don't make money. So if you want bloggers to attend your event and write about it, you ought to provide a small subsidy. Reporters for larger media outlets don't rely on that kind of support because they typically have expense accounts.

In case you're wondering, subsidies were once considered unethical. Yep. One of the things you learn in journalism school is that reporting should not be tainted or perceived to be tainted by gifts or benefits. In essence, restaurants, bars, beer festivals, etc., shouldn't be able to pay for good reviews or to avoid bad ones. Makes sense, eh?

The practice of providing subsidies to blogs became fairly common over the last 10 or so years mostly due to the collapse of traditional media. The decline of mainstream print and electronic media and the rise of digital and, eventually, social media, ushered in the need to recognize the promotional value of all outlets, including blogs like this one.

Some regard event subsidies as a form of payola. The Federal Communications Commission, which supposedly governs these things, has regulations that require the disclosure of these kinds of benefits. But media outlets, including blogs, rarely disclose such benefits. Why? Because the monetary value of the benefits received is typically small.

If there's a problem with that arrangement, it occurs when event organizers demand positive coverage in exchange for freebies. That's certainly the case with many beer festivals. Organizers can be thin-skinned and intolerant of negative reporting. That can and does lead to some fairly mealy-mouthed, worthless reviews. You've read them, I assure you.

In the case of the Holiday Ale Festival, they provided no explanation for the policy change. But it isn't that hard to figure out. The festival has grown to the point that organizers see no need for broad media support. As far as they're concerned, folks who normally rely on blog coverage of the event can look elsewhere...to TV or radio, perhaps.

The change won't prevent anyone from covering the event, though most local blogs seem to be ignoring it. Some may pay their way in for the privilege of mingling with brewers and tasting from a list of one-off beers. Theoretically, the credential situation could lead to more honest, critical reportage. But don't hold your breath. This is a major league brofest.

For my part, I've been increasingly uncomfortable with the recent direction of the Holiday Festival. The price of admission has spiraled upward ($35 this year, for a skimpy package) and the multi-token beers and VIP scenarios suggest the event has jumped the tracks. And don't get me started on the juvenile pin-up girl marketing graphic. What the hell are they thinking?

Organizers have generously offered media folks who pay their way in the opportunity to mingle with the festival's Great Oz, Preston Weesner, for special tastes and stimulating conversation. I suppose some will take them up on that offer. But I'll pass. And I urge others to do the same. Festival organizers handed blogs and their followers a lump of coal. We need to return the favor.

Wednesday, November 25, 2015

Annual Holiday Toy Drive in Motion at Laurelwood

As we enter the season of giving and charity, it's always great to hear about businesses that are stepping up to help the community. Craft beer is part of that. As has been the case for many years, Laurelwood Brewing is again sponsoring its annual Doernbecher Holiday Toy Drive.

Between now and Dec. 20, patrons can drop off a new and unwrapped toy at Laurelwood's Sellwood or Sandy Blvd. location. In exchange, donors may purchase a pint of Laurelwood brew for $1 or enjoy a non-alcoholic beverage for free.

"We have always been dedicated to helping area youth,” said Desi Riscol, Laurelwood Public House and Brewery Area Manager. "This year, it feels especially important to extend the power of kindness. We’re excited to help give the gift of a magical holiday season to the children and families spending it at Doernbecher."

Laurelwood is no stranger to fundraisers, having sponsored benefits for schools and a variety of related community causes dating back to 2001, when it launched Dine Out to Wipe Out Cancer.

"We've never viewed fundraisers as an obligation," said Mike De Kalb, Laurelwood founder and co-owner. "We do them to give back to the community, to support the people who support us. Schools are desperate for funds. Some kids and families need help at Christmas. [My wife] Cathy and I have lived in this community for almost 25 years and this is our way of giving back."

Of course, Laurelwood is far from the only craft beer-centric business that supports the community. Belmont Station routinely has benefits, such as the Black Friday Sneak Preview. The list goes on. Ninkasi, Widmer, Breakside and a host of others give back to the community regularly.

You'll find details related to the Doernbecher Holiday Toy Drive on the Laurelwood website here. It's sure to be another big success this year thanks to support from the community. The chance to enjoy good karma and a tasty beverage at a bargain price are just added benefits for those who donate.

Friday, November 20, 2015

Black Friday Preview at Belmont Station

One of the things you don't see much of here is promotional content. There's a reason for that, which is there are so many competing events happening all the time that I mostly choose to stay neutral. That doesn't make me very popular in some circles. Oh well.

But there are events that deserve mention. Next week's Bourbon County Stout Sneak Preview at Belmont Station is just such an event. It's happening Wednesday, the day before Thanksgiving from noon to 9 p.m. in the bier cafe at the Station.

Attendees will be tasting four rare versions of Goose Island's most renowned beer: 2015 Bourbon County Stout; Bourbon County Stout Barley Wine; Bourbon County Stout Regal Rye and Bourbon County Stout Coffee. These beers will be available in flights only for ticket holders.

Tickets are limited and must be purchased in advance at Belmont Station. The cost is $30 per ticket, which might seem like a lot until you consider how rare these beers are, You can purchase up to four tickets in advance, but you can only redeem one per person on the day of the event.

The cool thing is that $15 of every ticket sold will benefit the Oregon Food Bank. This is another case of Lisa Morrison and the crew at Belmont Station giving back to the community. They do something similar with the annual Pliny the Younger release. It's damn good stuff.


Just so I don't get called out for hypocrisy, I'm well aware of the fact that Goose Island is wholly owned by Anheuser-Busch. You won't typically find me supporting events or breweries connected to the evil empire. But this event is different. It transcends the beer wars.

Tickets to the Sneak Preview will almost certainly sell out. Keep in mind that you will only be able to taste the beers in question if you purchase a ticket in advance. Tickets will not be sold on the day of the event.

This is a great opportunity to enjoy some great beers while helping out the Oregon Food Bank, which needs all the help it can get this time of year. Kudos and thanks to my friends at Belmont Station for hosting this great event.

Tuesday, November 17, 2015

Ballast Point and the Homogenization of Craft Beer

Yesterday's news that Ballast Point Brewing is being bought by Constellation Brands sent shock waves through the industry. These were different waves than the ones we've seen with other buyouts. It's a sign of the times than few are shocked when craft breweries are bought by big beer.

What shocked people about the Ballast Point buyout is the price. Constellation will reportedly pay a cool $1 billion for the privilege of owning the San Diego brewery. That number surely has more than a few craft brewers wondering what they might sell for. Everyone has a price.

On its face, the valuation seems a little crazy. Ballast Point will sell about 280,000 barrels this year and expects revenue of $115 million. The 20-year-old company has shown solid growth in recent years. Still, Constellation paid a premium, roughly $3,500 per finished barrel. Earlier buyouts were in the $1,000 per barrel range.

Keep in mind that all of these buyouts are a two-way street. Constellation, the keeper of Corona and Modelo, was shopping for a strong craft partner. Ballast Point. which launched an IPO in October at least partially to finance further expansion, was ripe for a big money partner. Both are getting exactly what they wanted.

For its part, Constellation is looking very much to the future with this deal. Craft beer owns 11 percent of the US beer market, but Constellation expects that number to grow as mass market lagers decline. Don't downplay the importance of the Anheuser-Busch/SABMiller merger as motivation. Constellation wanted to secure its place at the craft table and saw Ballast Point as a plum.

Some have poo-pooed the value of Ballast Point. That's crazy. Located in one of the nation's best beer cities, BP has a broad portfolio of beers, many of which are well-regarded outside California...they distribute to more than 30 states. They also have a small collection of pubs. The stature of the brand and their expertise at running pubs means Ballast Point could conceivably open these things all over the country. And those are serious cash machines.

What we may be starting to see with these buyouts is the coming homogenization of craft beer in this country. In the same way that fast food and a multitude of other things have been homogenized over the last 40 or so years, we may well be seeing something similar with craft beer.


When I was a kid, the national chains didn't own the fast food market. There were still a lot of independently owned and operated, mom and pop places. The big chains were around, but independents were easier to find. Since that time, the big shots have almost completely taken over the fast food landscape.

Most of today's craft breweries and pubs are independent. Imagine for a moment what happens when you have well-financed chains operated by the likes of Ballast Point and 10 Barrel opening pubs everywhere. The pubs would be backed by packaged beer in stores. Remember, these operations will enjoy huge purchasing and logistical advantages over independent pubs. Well?

Even if the homogenization doesn't happen quite as I envision, these buyouts are changing the nature of craft beer. The lines are blurring. Regardless of what you or I or the Brewers Association thinks, Ballast Point and the other purchased brands will continue to operate as craft breweries.

What everyone needs to recognize is that these breweries, by way of their connection to big beer, enjoy substantial advantages over independent brewers. The craft beer playing field is in the process of becoming a lot less level than it has been. In a nutshell, that is the risk to independent craft brewers.


Friday, November 6, 2015

Laurelwood Moving 'Contract Brewing' to Full Sail

I'm not the type to troll the OLCC website looking for information on new breweries and pubs. It isn't worth my time because I don't care if I'm first to cover a story. I prefer to provide some perspective that often isn't part of breaking coverage.

Friday afternoon, one of my industry contacts gave me a heads up that Laurelwood has applied for a brewpub license in Hood River. "What could that mean?" he wondered. I immediately thought it might be related to the contract brewing situation. Sure enough.

"We're in the process of switching our contract brewing partner closer to home," Laurelwood owner Mike De Kalb told me via email. "The Craft Brew Alliance wants to get out of the contract brewing business and Full Sail has extra capacity, so it seemed like a natural fit."

Recall that the CBA has been brewing Laurelwood Workhorse and Free Range Red at its Woodinville, Wash. facility since 2013. That arrangement has been a big winner, getting those beers into six-packs of 12 ounce bottles, beer's most popular packaging. As well, the deal freed up production capacity in Portland, allowing brewers to focus on developing more specialty beers. The Full Sail partnership may be a further step in that direction.

"We expect the arrangement with Full Sail to give us added flexibility," De Kalb said. "We'll have more control of the processes and outcomes. The details are still being worked out, but I expect us to to be able to release seasonal beers in six-packs, something we couldn't do with the CBA."

Some are wondering why, if it's a contract brewing situation, Laurelwood applied for a brewpub license. There are reasons for everything.

"This is common in Oregon. Most breweries have a brewpub license," De Kalb said. "With Full Sail, we've worked out an alternating proprietorship agreement. It's a little technical and slightly different than contract brewing. As I said, the details are still being hammered out."


Moving their production brewing closer to home offers benefits. For starters, 75 percent of the Laurelwood beer produced in Woodinville (estimated at 18,000 barrels for 2015 earlier this year) returns to Oregon. Brewing that beer here means reduced shipping costs and fresher beer. It also means easier access to the day-to-day brewing operation.

In case you're wondering, production of Red Elephant cans will continue at the Portland brewery. I assume Full Sail does not have a canning line. At present, Laurelwood uses a mobile canning system for Red Elephant, which has been well-received since its release in cans last summer.

As for the CBA, you have to wonder why they would want to abandon contract brewing. Maybe they need the capacity for the popular Kona beers. No way do they need additional capacity for Redhook, a craft flat-liner. Perhaps they've contracted with Anheuser-Busch to brew wholly owned brands like Goose Island or 10 Barrel for the Northwest. Any such arrangement would be top secret, of course. 

In the case of Laurelwood, they expect to issue a formal press release when the details are fully worked out. The switch to Full Sail won't happen overnight. They anticipate Spring 2016.

Wednesday, October 28, 2015

Paradise by Buyout Light

There's nothing like a junket to the tropics to improve mental and physical dexterity. Wishful thinking, you know. These trips are more or less a regular thing, which means I've talked about the beer scene out here on many occasions. "Out here," of course, is code for Kauai. And it's a veritable desert in beer terms.

Looking at my social media and blog feed, I can't help but be amused and annoyed by some of the reporting. There are those in the blogging and writing community who continue to pander to and coddle breweries that are wholly owned by Anheuser-Busch. They know who they are and you know which breweries I'm talking about. This isn't rocket science.

I take a dim view of buyouts and sellouts and of AB's efforts to leverage its position globally and in the United States. Not everyone agrees or cares, but I think these buyouts are bad for craft beer, whatever that is these days. Anheuser-Busch hopes to purchase enough breweries and distributors to squeeze craft beer out of the comfort zone it enjoys today.

Upon arriving in Kauai, I got a firsthand snootful of what a buyout looks like to consumers. This happened at the car rental joint. I reserved a car several months ago via a website that offers options from among all or most of the car rental vendors here. I've used this approach to rent a car here for many years. This time, we rented from Thrifty.

It was pretty apparent we were in trouble the instant we got to the rental office. There was a line of customers and only two people behind the counter. Outside, a skeleton crew prepped cars that were going back out. Nearby, folks who had checked in and were ready to go waited patiently their vehicles. And waited.

As I reached the front of the line, a gent appeared from outside the ropes and told the agent he would need another car...that the car they gave him had a mechanical problem.  The agent smiled and said he would take care of that momentarily. There were a lot of vacant stares on the faces of people waiting in line. Expectations for a positive experience took a dive.

The agent taking care of my reservation had been to Portland a year or so ago and we struck up a friendly conversation. As he was finishing things up, I discreetly asked him what the hell was going on with Thrifty. I'd rented from them before and never seen a disaster like this.

"We were bought out by Hertz," he said. "A few weeks ago, they came in and switched us to a new computer system, cut staffing and made a mess." He had told me at the start that he had to access another site to find the details of my reservation. The entire process took nearly an hour, for something that typically takes 15-20 minutes in Kauai. Not good.

Of course, there's more to the story. The Hertz buyout of Thrifty didn't just happen. It happened in 2012. But Hertz has been busy dealing with the anti-trust issues that came out of its purchase of Thrifty and Dollar. Hertz had to offload domestic locations of subsidiary Advantage. It evidently took them a while to bring the various locations into the Hertz orbit. Small favors.

In fact, only three companies–Hertz, Avis and Enterprise–control 94 percent of the car rental industry in America. Recent consolidation in the industry, including Hertz' buyout of Dollar and Thrifty, has led to dramatic price increases, as discussed here. Funny how reduced competition leads to fewer choices, higher prices and less attentive service. Huge surprise.

Could this kind of scenario occur in the beer world? Maybe not. But Anheuser-Busch's strategy of buying craft breweries and distributors is alarming. It will enable them to limit access to the market for non-AB brands while their owned "craft "brands, brewed in factory breweries, become readily available. If there's an upside, I don't see it.

Obviously, the significant question is how many people know or care about what's going on in the beer wars. Here on Kauai, I see plenty of people drinking Bud Light or similar garbage. I wonder if they know or care what that choice means. Sounds like a topic for future discussion.

Aloha

Sunday, October 25, 2015

Oregon's First Brewpub Turns 30

Today marks in important milestone in Oregon history. But you aren't likely to see any coverage in the mainstream media. Why? Because it has nothing to do with the Kardashians or Star Wars or Back to the Future or a mass shooting. Nope.
Mike and Brian with Ron Wolf

Thirty years ago today McMenamins brewed the first batch of beer at their Hillsdale pub. Why is that significant? Because it made Hillsdale the first brewpub in modern Oregon history. The Brewpub Bill, passed in June 1985, paved the way for them to establish a brewery in an existing pub.

It may be instructive to recall that Bridgeport and Widmer were both brewing at that point. Bridgeport was actually selling beer by late 1984. The Widmers were right behind them and began selling beer in April 1985. But neither had a pub. Hillsdale was the first.

Those early Hillsdale beers were brewed with malt extract and other suspect ingredients. Not the best approach and, in fact, the beers were not especially good. Don't take my word for it. I didn't get here until 1989. Brian McMenamin provided his thoughts during a 2013 interview.
We weren’t really sure what the Brewpub Bill meant at first. Did it mean cooking beer on a stove in the kitchen? We knew we could use old dairy equipment. So we went down to Tillamook and found some tanks, jerry-rigged some stuff and it worked. We started making beer and it wasn’t good beer. We hired some people to help with it and we eventually had some decent stuff.
One of the people they hired was John Harris, who would become one of Oregon's iconic brewers at Deschutes and Full Sail before launching Ecliptic in 2013. By 1985, Harris had done some homebrewing, but had no pro experience. There were very few pro craft brewers in those days.. Head brewer Ron Wolf hired him, anyway. Harris recalled his experience in 2013.
On my first day at Hillsdale, I was supposed to bring rubber boots…but I forgot to buy them. I had to wear my hiking boots, which didn’t work very well. Fortunately, they didn't fire me. The system was tiny…about seven kegs. We had no temperature control and we used open fermenters. Consistency was a problem. Beers sometimes got a little sour. The whole concept of small breweries was revolutionary. The brewers at Henry Weinhard considered us renegades because our brewery was so primitive. We got some respect and the beer got better after we started mashing. 
The brewpub concept didn't take off instantly. But combining food with beer produced in tiny, on-site breweries eventually became a thing. Bridgeport established a pub and Portland Brewing opened on Northwest Flanders in March 1986. McMenamin's eventually established breweries in a number of their pubs, which became destinations because you could always find good beer there.


In the greater scheme of things, brewpubs were crucial to the development of our beer culture because they exposed people of all ages to craft beer in a friendly environment. If not for brewpubs, craft beer would have been relegated largely to the dark shadows of taverns and bars, and it's visibility would have suffered. We would not be where we are today.

To celebrate 30 years, a commemorative version of Hillsdale Ale will be poured at all McMenamin's locations today. No, this won't be a malt extract beer. They've examined the brewing notes from that original beer and recreated it to the best of their ability in an all-grain format. Pints of Hillsdale Ale will go for $4. Growler fills will be $8.

As most who follow the local beer scene know, the McMenamins pursued a different course than virtually all of the other craft or micro breweries. They never had any desire to distribute their beer beyond their own pubs and assorted properties. Their plan was wildly simplistic.

"Instead of buying it from someone else, we wanted to brew the beer to sell in our pubs," Brian McMenamin recalled. "If you haven't figured it out, we're stubborn Irish people. We like doing things ourselves."

You might say that stubborn, do-it-yourself approach has served and guided the brothers well over the years. And if you did, I'm pretty sure you'd be right.